Old Navy alternatives: STAPLE Co, Vottera and 15 more, scored
Compare scored sweatshirts, hoodies, and shorts outside Old Navy using disclosed fiber blends, finishes, and certifications.
Use the product list to compare disclosed materials and scores for everyday casual wear; availability changes at the retailer. Old Navy products are excluded from the ranking.
Top-scoring alternatives we have analyzed
213 scored products are ranked above 70/100 in this space, excluding Old Navy.
Hoodie - Regenerative Organic Certified
STAPLE Co
Unisex Organic Cotton Sweatshirts
Vottera
Organic Linen Trunks
Heavenly Essentials
Men's 100% European Linen Short Sleeve Shirt
Quince
100% European Linen Drawstring Beach Shorts - 7"
Quince
100% European Linen Short Sleeve Shirt
Quince
The Linen Short
Vessel of Thrns
Everyday Shorts for Men - Organic Cotton Jersey
STAPLE Co
Organic Waffle Crewneck Sweatshirt
Mate the Label
Allwear Organic Cropped Half-Zip Hoodie
Allwear
Women's Cotton Deep V-Neck Tee
Citizen Wolf
Organic Cotton Commando Short (3 PACK)
NADS
Short Sleeve Resort Shirt
PLAINANDSIMPLE
Allwear Organic Half-Zip Hoodie 2.0
Allwear
Active Cotton Unlined Short
Nero
Organic Fleece Quarter Zip Sweatshirt
MATE the Label
Organic Cotton Shorts
The Merrimack Company
Active Merino Liner Short
Nero
![[AT46.OC] Shorts - Black](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fbqqnvxt3rjmsfusr.public.blob.vercel-storage.com%2Fproducts%2F1b64b3d7c395bb82e61bd16033646c50.jpg&w=3840&q=75)
[AT46.OC] Shorts - Black
Boldwill
100% Plastic-Free Organic Cotton Shorts
MARO
The Apex Short
Ryker
Allwear Organic 7’’ Sweat Shorts 2.0 3 Pack
Allwear
The Apex Short - (100% Organic Cotton + 100% Merino Wool Liner)
Ryker Clothing Co
Men's Drawstring Lounge Shorts
Cottonique
Related category guides
People shopping for Old Navy alternatives often want to compare across the whole category. These guides rank scored products and explain what the fiber label can tell you.
Other brand alternatives
Each of these pages ranks scored products outside a different brand, using the same disclosed-material method.
Best next step
Have a specific Old Navy item you are about to buy? Paste the product URL into the analyzer for a side-by-side score before checkout.
Common questions
What does this Old Navy alternatives page compare?
It ranks scored products that are not made by Old Navy, using disclosed fiber blends, finishes, certifications, and Greener Closet scores. It does not treat Old Navy as a single product or make a brand-wide safety claim.
How does Greener Closet score these alternatives?
Each product starts at 100 and is scored from its disclosed material composition and available certification information. Material-level penalties across six factors are combined in proportion to the garment's stated fiber blend. Read the methodology page for the process, data boundaries, and limitations.
Are these alternatives all higher scoring than Old Navy?
Not necessarily. Every listed product is scored 70 or higher and is not made by Old Navy, but the list does not claim to beat every Old Navy item. Paste the exact product URL into the analyzer for a direct comparison.