Old Navy alternatives ranked for non-toxic picks
Looking for Old Navy alternatives that score higher on health and sustainability? These are the highest-scoring everyday basics we have analyzed across tees, denim, and family apparel.
Top-scoring alternatives we have analyzed
538 scored products are ranked above 70/100 in this space, excluding Old Navy.
100% Regenerative Organic Certified® Cotton - Layering Tee
Brand: Maggie's Organics
Holiday Dear Deer HannaJams™ Sleeper
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Low-Rise Straight Jean | Tungsten Old Blue
Brand: Everlane
The Beachcomber Relaxed Jean
Brand: Outerknown
Baggy Rigid Jean
Brand: Everlane
The Dunes Straight Jean
Brand: Outerknown
Halloween HannaJams™ Pajama Set
Brand: Hanna Andersson
HannaJams™ Footed Sleeper
Brand: Hanna Andersson
The Way-High® Gardener Cropped Jean
Brand: Everlane
Everyday Trunk 4-Pack
Brand: PACT
Baby animal friends organic zip footie 5-pack gift set
Brand: Primary
Baby Earth Day 2-Way Zip Shortie Sleeper
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Clearance Grateful Dead x Pact Graphic Tee
Brand: Pact
Oversized Midweight Tee
Brand: Everlane
Baby Holiday Zip Sleeper
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Adult Holiday Dear Deer Long John Pajama Top
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Men's '73 Skyline T-Shirt
Brand: Patagonia
Men's Fitz Roy Trout T-Shirt
Brand: Patagonia
STAR WARS™: The Mandalorian Women's Long John Pajama Top
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Holiday Dear Deer HannaJams™ Pajama Set
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Disney Mickey Mouse HannaJams™ Pajama Set
Brand: Hanna Andersson
Men's Repair Shop T-Shirt
Brand: Patagonia
Crew Neck Organic T-Shirt
Brand: PLAINANDSIMPLE
Organic Floral Mushroom Print Pyjamas
Brand: Toby Tiger
Related non-toxic clothing guides
People shopping for Old Navy alternatives often want to compare across the whole category. These guides explain which materials and finishes to look for and avoid.
Best next step
Have a specific Old Navy item you are about to buy? Paste the product URL into the analyzer for a side-by-side score before checkout.
Common questions
Why look for Old Navy alternatives?
Many shoppers compare Old Navy to higher-scoring options to avoid synthetic blends, water- and stain-repellent finishes that can carry PFAS, and high microfiber-shedding fabrics. The picks here are ranked by Greener Closet's health and sustainability score.
How does Greener Closet score these alternatives?
Each product is scored from its full material label and any available certifications. The score weights microplastics at 45%, PFAS at 15%, half-life and biodegradability at 15%, energy at 10%, azo dyes at 10%, and fiber shedding at 5%.
Are these alternatives all higher scoring than Old Navy?
Yes. Every product on this page is scored 70 or higher and is not made by Old Navy. If you want a more direct comparison, paste the exact Old Navy product URL into the analyzer.